A Grieving Heart vs Harmonic Symphony finished November 21st

PianoNinja challenged meline910 9 years ago Votes: 18 Views: 1,027

Winner: A Grieving Heart by PianoNinja

A Grieving Heart (5:04)
Harmonic Symphony (4:44)

My two favorite songs on musicshake, which one will triumph? :)

Head to head song stats
A Grieving Heart
Song title
Harmonic Symphony
PianoNinja
Created by
meline910
5:04
Song length
4:44
Rock/Metal
Genre
Classical/New Age
Love/Romantic
Mood
Longing/Anticipating
Other
Theme
Other
407
Plays
113
40
Ratings
3
158
Comments
13
61%
Vote %
38%
Add your comment

Please login or signup to comment

RyanYap1 - 9 years ago

It seems u guys are friends!!!!!

meline910 - 9 years ago

Just online friends for months. But we have a pretty friendly relationship I guess. XD

PianoNinja - 9 years ago

I guess you can say that. We've never met, just sorta online friends! :))

MaxJLee - 9 years ago

Hard decision :/

PianoNinja - 9 years ago

How does this have 114 views and 14 votes already!? :O

PianoNinja - 9 years ago

lol

meline910 - 9 years ago

The world may never know! XD

FutureStar12 - 9 years ago

i like both songs but i choose Grieving Heart

meline910 - 9 years ago

Thanks for voting!

PianoNinja - 9 years ago

:)

Pyrefox - 9 years ago

After recording both songs and listening to them both for a whole day, i will have to go with Harmonic Symphony by meline910. I chose it because i feel it really conveys what is happening in my life at the moment and I can really relate to that. I love both of these songs very much, and the choice was very hard. Congrats to both of you guys for making awesome songs. Musicshake need more composers like you.

PianoNinja - 9 years ago

Thank you, congrats meline910!! :D

Pyrefox - 9 years ago

No problem! I really appreciate it.

meline910 - 9 years ago

Thank you for your vote and for your encouraging words. Without someone like you, I don't think neither me nor PianoNinja would be so dedicated to composing songs. I am glad that you could relate to my song, it makes me happy.

ccollins - 9 years ago

Both amazing songs, but at times, I felt that meline's song was a bit clustered, so for that reason, PianoNinja gets my vote. :)

meline910 - 9 years ago

Thank you for the feedback, I will improve on that area!

ccollins - 9 years ago

It's always nice to see some good sportsmanship going on too. :D I respect you both. :)

PianoNinja - 9 years ago

Thanks for your support, ccollins! ^_^

DannaWilson - 9 years ago

a grieving heart was better than harmonic symphony!

meline910 - 9 years ago

Glad to hear!

DannaWilson - 9 years ago

yaaaaa

PianoNinja - 9 years ago

:) Thank you for becoming a fan! :)

DannaWilson - 9 years ago

tbh

DannaWilson - 9 years ago

I did like them both very much!

PianoNinja - 9 years ago

I hope you liked Harmonic Symphony anyway, it's still a fantastic song! ^_^

PianoNinja - 9 years ago

Everybody please listen to Harmonic Symphony, leave a review, rate, and fave if you like please! :D

DaanVester - 9 years ago

Very close but i think im gonna vote harmonic symphony

PianoNinja - 9 years ago

:D

meline910 - 9 years ago

No matter who wins PianoNinja your a great composer and thanks to everyone who voted or viewed either of the songs.

meline910 - 9 years ago

That means alot! If I don't end up winning I will keep at it until the day I am at or above your level. This battle was really getting to me and I needed to hear that. Thanks

PianoNinja - 9 years ago

You're a really great composer too! LudicoloBeat is right, you have such great sportsmanship - that's hard to come by these days! Just know no matter what happens that your song ROCKS, and I'd love to see more like it!! ;D